Churches Win as Illinois Capitulates on Worship Limitations


The Thomas More Society is claiming victory as the Illinois Department of Health released a statement issuing, “COVID-19 Guidance for Places of Worship and Providers of Religious Services Overview.” Governor “JB” Pritzker, the target of three separate Illinois lawsuits by the Thomas More Society, charging religious discrimination and violations of the United States and Illinois constitutions and Illinois’ Religious Freedom Restoration Act, announced in his daily press briefing on May 28, 2020 that he is withdrawing mandates on Illinois churches and replacing them with health department “guidelines” for places of worship.

“This is a total and complete victory for people of faith,” said Thomas More Society Vice President and Senior Counsel Peter Breen.

“This is a total and complete victory for people of faith,” declared Thomas More Society Vice President and Senior Counsel Peter Breen. “Illinois’ governor and his administration abused the COVID-19 pandemic to stomp on the religious liberty of the people of Illinois. By issuing guidelines only and not the previously announced mandatory restrictions, he has handed a complete victory to the churches in Illinois.”

Breen stated, “Today, people of faith across Illinois should breathe a little freer, as their government has finally recognized their fundamental freedom of religion. This right is written in the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution and it is critical to a self-governing democracy. But the pastors and churches of Illinois should not have had to file repeated lawsuits in state and federal courts to secure their basic rights. Today marks the end of a shameful chapter of discrimination by the government of the Land of Lincoln against houses of worship and religious leaders.”

Breen sees Pritzker’s capitulation as a direct result of the three lawsuits, one by The Beloved Church in Lena, another by Jesus House Restoration Ministries in Urbana, and a third, filed May 27, by a group of five Lake County churches and their pastors. The Lake County case was set for a hearing on a Temporary Restraining Order on May 29, 2020. After the first lawsuit by The Beloved Church, Pritzker lifted restrictions on “drive-in” services and small group gatherings, and following the complaint filed by Jesus House Restoration Ministries, he removed restrictions on outdoor worship services. Now he has lifted all mandates against how and where the churches and people of Illinois can practice their religion.

The guidelines issued by Pritzker’s health officials state that their purpose is to provide “guidance for places of worship and providers of religious services to support the safest possible environment for faith leaders, employees, volunteers, scholars, and all other types of workers, as well as congregants, worshipers, and visitors.” The statement recommends “Remote Services and Drive-In Services” as the “Safest Options,” and urges social distancing, face masks, limiting capacity, as well as excluding singing, refreshments, and close physical contact. The document also details recommended sanitation protocols.

“Today marks a huge win for all Illinoisans,” Breen reiterated. He explained how Pritzker’s autocratic abuse of power prompted multiple lawsuits by churches and pastors around the state. “Governor Pritzker had imposed various limits on church activities as part of his coronavirus stay-at-home orders. After each of the three Thomas More Society lawsuits, Pritzker reversed course and lifted restrictions that he had previously stated he would maintain.”

The three lawsuits in which the Thomas More Society triumphed over the governor are:

  • The Christian Assembly of God, et al v. Jay Robert Pritzker, Governor of Illinois (available here) filed May 27, 2020, with the Illinois Circuit Court for the Nineteenth Judicial District – Lake County, Illinois
  • Jesus House Restoration Ministries and Dustin Brown v. Jay Robert Pritzker (available here) filed May 12, 2020, with the United States District Court for the Central District of Illinois Western Division
  • The Beloved Church, et al v. Jay Robert Pritzker, et al (available here) filed April 30, 2020, with the United States District Court for the Northern District of Illinois Western Division