Calvin Robinson is facing calls for a review of his American visa after telling a podcast that “driving out the Jews” was the answer to what he described as the subversion of Christian society. The British-born cleric’s remarks have drawn criticism from Jewish lawyers and commentators on the political right, while his own media organisation has issued a defiant statement defending him.
The American Association of Jewish Lawyers and Jurists has written to Rabbi Yehuda Kaploun, the State Department’s special envoy to monitor and combat antisemitism, asking the federal government to examine whether grounds exist to revoke Robinson’s visa. The letter was reported by Jewish News Syndicate in an article republished by the Cleveland Jewish News on 20 November.
“Robinson’s remarks betray not only a disturbing hostility toward Jews but a breathtaking ignorance of American history and the principles upon which this republic was founded,” the association’s president, Robert Garson, wrote. “His vision is not merely antisemitic. It is fundamentally un-American.”
Robinson made the comments on the 13 November edition of *The Command Show*, during a discussion involving Joe Enders, whom JNS describes as a white nationalist. According to a transcript published by Right Wing Watch, Enders complained of a “Jewish oligarchy” and asked how its supposed influence could be prevented from reaching the highest levels of government.
“In answer to Joe’s question, quite frankly, it’s driving out the Jews,” Robinson replied. “We can talk about mass deportation of Mohammedans and other peoples that are contradictory to our own way of life in Christendom, but we can’t discuss it in terms of the Jews. I think driving out the Jews is the answer.”
He accused Jews of being disproportionately represented in industries “subverting our culture”, including Hollywood and music, and said they should move to Israel: “You’ve now got your homeland that you fought for, you can go and live in your homeland … you can stop taking over ours.”
Robinson framed his argument in explicitly religious terms. “It’s not Judeo-Christian, which comes from that same dual covenant heresy,” he said. “This is an explicitly Christian land for an explicitly Christian people.”
Garson’s response challenged both the proposed exclusion of Jewish Americans and Robinson’s claim to speak for the country’s identity. “American Jews need no instruction from Calvin Robinson on what it means to be American,” he wrote. “Their contribution to this nation is written into its founding, its defense, its institutions and its achievements.”
The association asked the State Department and Department of Homeland Security to determine whether Robinson’s “advocacy for the collective exclusion of an entire community of American citizens” provided grounds for action under immigration law. The report describes a request for a review, not an announced government decision to revoke his visa.
Criticism has not been confined to Jewish organisations or Robinson’s opponents on the left. Writing on 20 November, conservative commentator David Vance called the remarks “simply naked antisemitism” and said Robinson had unambiguously advocated the deportation of Jews from the United States.
An article published by Spiked on 21 November, “Calvin Robinson: the making of an anti-Semite”, presented the episode as the culmination of a developing pattern rather than an isolated provocation. It argued that Robinson had moved from recognisable conservative commentary into conspiracy theories that assign collective responsibility to Jews for Western society’s problems.
Robinson has shown no sign of withdrawing the remarks. The National Pulse reported that he responded to the circulation of the podcast clip on 19 November by writing: “No lies were told.”
The clearest organised support has come from Command Media, where Robinson serves as managing director. In a statement headed “A Formal Apology for Fr. Calvin Robinson’s Comments”, its board wrote: “There is none. Christ is King, you idiots.”
The statement accused critics of misrepresenting Robinson as attacking anyone of Jewish ancestry. It claimed instead that he meant “‘The Jews’ (seen several places in John’s Gospel)” whom it accused of dominating culture and acting with “a perfidious spirit of antichrist behind it”. It also rejected religious pluralism as incompatible with Western Christian society and repeated accusations of “Jewish oligarchy”.
Among those Command named as critics were Harmeet Dhillon, Laura Loomer and Ezra Levant. Its statement therefore offered not an apology but a theological and political defence of Robinson’s position, while continuing to employ collective accusations against Jews.
The contrast with Robinson’s earlier public identity is marked. He became known in Britain as a pro-Brexit, anti-lockdown commentator and critic of progressive politics, appearing on television and eventually presenting “Calvin’s Common Sense Crusade” on GB News. He lost his position at the broadcaster after supporting Lawrence Fox during the controversy over Fox’s remarks about a female journalist.
In its account of his subsequent development, Spiked traces a shift from criticism of political and ecclesiastical liberalism towards increasingly sweeping claims about hidden enemies. It notes that, when leaving Britain in 2024, Robinson spoke of fears of assassination by an “anonymous Mohammedan” or arrest by what he called Sir Keir Starmer’s “Satanic” government.
His ecclesiastical position also evolved. In January 2025, the Anglican Catholic Church revoked his licence following a straight-arm gesture at the National Pro-Life Summit in Washington that was widely interpreted as an imitation of Elon Musk’s controversial salute. Robinson denied antisemitism and denied that the gesture signalled Nazi allegiance.
The Anglican Catholic Church’s subsequent account said concerns about antisemitic statements, or sympathy with antisemitic groups, had already been raised. Robinson had disavowed antisemitism in writing after being warned against further provocation, the church said. It concluded that he had repeatedly demonstrated a lack of “the temperament and prudence needed in a parish priest”.
By late 2025, according to Spiked, Robinson was alleging that “there are too many perverted Jews running society” and blaming Jewish involvement in pornography, Hollywood and music for cultural corruption. The magazine also cited his sharing of inaccurate AI-generated figures about Holocaust survivors, accompanied by the comment “The math ain’t mathing”, as evidence of Holocaust minimisation.
In September 2026 he posted: “It is the Jews. It has always been the Jews. Not all of them, but always them.” The latest call for expulsion follows that progression from attacking particular ideas and institutions to identifying Jews collectively as the source of social disorder.
Robinson’s trajectory has parallels with those of Candace Owens and Tucker Carlson. All three have moved from prominent positions in conservative media into controversies over Jews, Israel and the influence of explicitly antisemitic voices. The evidence does not, however, justify treating their statements as interchangeable.
Owens’s departure from the Daily Wire in March 2024 followed months of conflict over comments condemned as antisemitic, including claims about Jewish groups in Hollywood and her approval of a social-media post invoking the accusation that Jews consume Christian blood. Her subsequent independent broadcasting has featured increasingly explicit conspiracy theories about Jews, according to the American Jewish Committee.
Her use of Christian language also provides a point of comparison. Owens announced her reception into the Roman Catholic Church in April 2024, and had already adopted “Christ is King” as a recurring online declaration during her dispute with Ben Shapiro. That phrase is an ordinary Christian confession; the controversy concerns the accusations and political arguments with which it is being associated, including Command Media’s deployment of it.
A December 2025 study by the Jewish People Policy Institute, reported by the Jewish Telegraphic Agency, identified a significant distinction between Owens and Carlson. Using AI-assisted analysis of approximately 3,000 YouTube videos, the institute classified three-quarters of Owens’s videos mentioning Jews in the latter half of the period examined as antisemitic, up from 45 per cent in the earlier period. Those figures represent the study’s algorithmic classifications, rather than an independently established measure.
For Carlson, the same study found increasingly negative treatment of Israel and repeated provision of an “uncritical platform to well-known antisemites”, including Nick Fuentes. But it did not identify “consistent or explicit antisemitic statements” in Carlson’s own content. That distinction matters: criticism of Israeli policy, hosting an antisemitic guest and personally advocating the removal of Jewish citizens are different actions.
Carlson’s relationship with Fuentes has also become more contentious. A 20 November roundup by Media Matters reported that Carlson had recently said he “fell for” having Fuentes on his programme “like an idiot”, while Fuentes had publicly attacked Carlson. That complicates any account of an uninterrupted alliance between them.
Robinson’s latest remarks go beyond the platforming controversy surrounding Carlson. Like the rhetoric attributed to Owens, they assign collective blame to Jews; unlike the conduct principally criticised in Carlson’s case, they expressly propose expulsion as a political remedy.
Robinson’s clerical identity gives the dispute a significance beyond the online right’s arguments over Israel. He presented exclusion not simply as a nationalist policy but as a requirement of an explicitly Christian society, while Command Media invoked John’s Gospel in defending him.
The immediate dispute concerns what consequences, if any, should follow for Robinson’s immigration status. Robinson, who just announced is engagement this month, to a US citizen is not likely to be deported over his remarks. The wider controversy concerns his attempt to turn Christian claims about truth and national identity into an argument that Jewish Americans do not belong in the United States — an argument his critics condemn as both antisemitic and incompatible with American religious liberty.