HomeOp-EdWhat use are the Lords Spiritual?

What use are the Lords Spiritual?

Published on

Please Help Anglican.Ink with a donation.

Defenders of the Anglican establishment often cite as one of its benefits the ‘Bishops’ Bench’ in the House of Lords. This body of 26 prelates installed by historic right in our upper chamber represents, so they say, a Christian voice at the heart of our legislature – a set up unique among modern western democracies. How true are these claims?

Shortly before he died in April of this year, my father Lord Robert Skidelsky commissioned a little research into this question. He asked his invaluable assistant, Attila Mestehazy, to run through all 693 speeches delivered by the reverend Lords between 1 January 2024 and 19 September 2025, looking out especially for words and arguments associated with Christianity. The results were dismaying, if not entirely unexpected. ‘Bible’, ‘gospel’ and ‘Christianity’ each appear in somewhat under one per cent of all bishops’ speeches. ‘Jesus’ appears in three per cent. ‘God’ shows up a bit more often, at six per cent, perhaps indicating an attempt at inter-faith solidarity. ‘Sin’ appears not at all.

It is not that the bishops are morally cold or indifferent. On the contrary, their speeches drip with social concern. Anguish over the ‘most vulnerable’ in our community, particularly ‘minoritised women’, ‘LGBT+ victims’ and those suffering ‘intersecting forms of discrimination’, is richly on display. ‘Mental health’ crops up in almost seven per cent of the bishops’ interventions, ‘wellbeing’ in eight per cent – more than ‘God’ and ‘Jesus’. The Church of England was once the Tory party at prayer. Now it is the welfare state at prayer.

A deeper dive into the 693 speeches confirms the impression of overwhelming secularity. On most issues, the bishops take a position indistinguishable from the left wing of the Labour party, albeit decked out occasionally in Christian rhetoric. …

Read it all in The Spectator

Latest articles

Blowback begins over Synod vote on Palestine — Eastern Daily Press holds Bishop of Norwich up to ridicule

Norfolk bishop supports 'shameful' vote condemned by Chief Rabbi A Norfolk bishop who warned antisemitism...

Synod debates the Church Commissioners approach to land use and nature

In a debate on Tuesday morning, General Synod debated a private member’s motion regarding...

The Church of England and Israel/Palestine

On Sunday evening, General Synod debate the Carlisle Diocesan motion (which they had passed...

Board publishes briefing for General Synod members on the Kairos Palestine Motion

If this motion is implemented, it will have immediate harmful consequences for British Jews...

Board of Deputies President; ‘Motion passed at Church of England Synod is a prescription for more division’

President of the Board of Deputies Phil Rosenberg has described as “highly problematic” a...

More like this

Blowback begins over Synod vote on Palestine — Eastern Daily Press holds Bishop of Norwich up to ridicule

Norfolk bishop supports 'shameful' vote condemned by Chief Rabbi A Norfolk bishop who warned antisemitism...

Synod debates the Church Commissioners approach to land use and nature

In a debate on Tuesday morning, General Synod debated a private member’s motion regarding...

The Church of England and Israel/Palestine

On Sunday evening, General Synod debate the Carlisle Diocesan motion (which they had passed...