A comparison between two dioceses in the latest Church of England mission statistics highlights the benefits of maintaining and preferably increasing the numbers of frontline clergy in parishes.
The C of E press release proclaimed last week: ‘Church attendance grows for fifth year in a row. More than a million people regularly attend Church of England services, full annual statistics published today confirm, showing that congregations saw their fifth year of growth in 2025.
‘The worshipping community, made up of regular church attenders, grew 1.5 per cent in 2025, to 1.03 million, while all age average weekly attendance rose by 0.8 per cent or 6,000, to 707,000. The number of children attending church regularly rose by 8,000 over the period 2024/25. Average Sunday attendance grew by 1.6 per cent, or 9,000, to 590,000, according to the Church of England’s Statistics for Mission 2025.’
But lower down in the proclamation, the C of E admitted: ‘Despite this growth, attendance and participation remain below pre-pandemic levels.’
Indeed. In 2019, the all-age average weekly attendance was 864,000 and the average Sunday attendance was 716,000.
Now for the comparison between two dioceses serving similarly sized populations in the North of England. Blackburn Diocese serves 1.384 million people in Lancashire and Sheffield Diocese 1.278 million in South Yorkshire. But the average all-age weekly attendances at their churches are very different.
Sheffield had 12,900 people going through its doors over an average week in 2025, up from 12,600 in 2024 whereas Blackburn had 17,800 up from 16,800 in 2024.
How has Blackburn managed to draw nearly 5000 more people into its churches than Sheffield and grow by 1000 in that year? In the annex to the questions notice paper for the November 2026 General Synod, data about the numbers of stipendiary parochial clergy of incumbent status (full time equivalent) across dioceses are highly revealing. Sheffield has 82 frontline incumbents serving 140 benefices and 164 parishes whereas Blackburn has 124 serving 167 benefices and 223 parishes.
A news story in February 2019 in the Sheffield Star headlined ‘Sheffield clergy numbers set to be slashed as dwindling congregations and crumbling buildings force rethink’ reported that at the end of 2018 the diocese had 103 stipendiary incumbents.
Isn’t it now high time the leadership of the Church of England admitted that cutting parochial clergy numbers and creating ‘oversight’ or ‘focal’ ministry posts is just not working for mission and growth on the ground?
Julian Mann, a former Church of England vicar, is an evangelical journalist based in Lancashire, UK.