An assistant priest on the staff of Trinity Episcopal Church on the Green in New Haven, Connecticut, has been charged with five counts of animal cruelty following the deaths and severe injuries of multiple dogs in her care. The Rev. Lisa Levy, 48, of Hamden, was arrested on February 20, 2026, after veterinarians reported suspicious patterns of chemical burns, neurological issues, and other trauma in animals she handled.

Police launched an investigation on January 28, 2026, after a North Haven veterinarian flagged a 10-year-old Chihuahua mix named Chanco, which arrived with “horrendous” burns on its flesh. Court documents reveal Levy cared for five dogs—Chanco, Zuba, Yelenda, Wanda, and Steve—all exhibiting similar symptoms like chemical burns, cuts, broken bones, and sudden neurological problems; three died from their conditions. Additional records show a history dating back to 2011, with other pets under Levy’s care suffering mysterious illnesses, being euthanized, or returned to rescues despite initial vetting by organizations.

Levy’s boyfriend reportedly blamed accidents like stair falls, but investigators noted inconsistencies. Levy was released on $15,000 bond, with a court date set for March 6, 2026; the Hamden Police investigation continues.

Trinity Episcopal Church placed Levy, who served as the historic parish’s community care minister, on immediate administrative leave. In a statement attributed to its rector, the Rev. Luk De Volder, the church expressed grief: “This is a tragic situation, and we grieve it. As people of faith, we know that what God has made is sacred. As people whose lives are enriched by the companionship of animals, we know they must be treated with care, respect, and dignity.”

The church notified the Episcopal Diocese of Connecticut, which is providing guidance, though no separate statement from the diocese or its bishop has surfaced publicly.